Crooner Vinyl Records: Sinatra, Nat King Cole and the Great Voices
Why crooner records sound right on vinyl
Crooner vinyl records make historical sense: crooning grew up with the electric microphone, which let singers sing softly, almost in the listener's ear, and it peaked just as the LP took over. The great albums by Frank Sinatra and Nat King Cole were built as full records with a mood held from start to finish. This selection covers the classic voices, from Bing Crosby to Dean Martin, Tony Bennett, Johnny Mathis and Peggy Lee, along with modern heirs such as Harry Connick Jr., Michael Bublé, Jamie Cullum and Josh Groban.
Essential crooner albums
For Frank Sinatra, the 1950s Capitol years are among the most sought after: "In the Wee Small Hours" (1955) for late-night ballads, "Songs for Swingin' Lovers!" (1956) for swing with Nelson Riddle's arrangements. Nat King Cole's "Love Is the Thing" (1957) is a benchmark orchestral record, and Tony Bennett's "I Left My Heart in San Francisco" (1962) a Columbia classic. Dean Martin, Bing Crosby and Johnny Mathis also left Christmas albums that come back as reissues every winter. Among later records, Tony Bennett's "Cheek to Cheek" (2014) with Lady Gaga introduced the style to a younger audience.
Original pressings or reissues?
Many 1950s albums were first issued in mono: the stereo LP only reached the market in 1958. For those records the original mono mix is often the one fans prefer, and several recent reissues offer it. Used copies on Capitol, Columbia, Reprise or Verve are still fairly affordable, but check groove wear, since many were played on heavy vintage tonearms. For regular listening, a recent reissue on new vinyl avoids crackle. Check the jacket or sticker to see whether it was mastered from the original tapes or from a digital source.